Tuesday, November 4, 2025

2025 Topps Shoebox Treasures #15

.              

Card Review: 9.5

When I was around 8 or 9 years old, probably in about 1989, my mother drew me a detailed replica of the 1988 Topps All-Star card using colored pencils.  It was probably about 11'' x 17'' in size, though I remember it to be bigger, and I believe drawn on a heavy stock water color paper.  My mother had been a design major at Syracuse and was (is) very talented when it comes to these things.  At the time, all the neighborhood kids had discovered a store at Metro Center Mall in Phoenix that sold large posters of MLB stars.  Everyone on the block was getting a poster of their favorite player.  Even my younger brother got in on the act, proudly pinning a large Mark McGwire poster to our shared bedroom wall.

So while the likes of Don Mattingly, Darryl Strawberry, Will Clark, Eric Davis, and Ryne Sandberg were being displayed across the rooms of kids all over Moon Valley, I was left out in the cold as Tim Wallach was not among the players offered for sale.  My mother, taking pity on me, took it upon herself to do the best she could with a homemade effort.  Initially, I didn't care for it.  I thought it was embarrassing.  Reluctantly I hung it on my wall.  To my surprise, not only was I not mocked for it, the other kids liked it when they saw it.  Liked it so much in fact that my mother received multiple calls from the parents offering to pay her to draw similar ones.  She declined, but the homemade poster became a source of pride.

I don't know what happened to that drawing.  Its been lost to time, along with my brothers Mark McGwire poster and every other item to ever adorn our bedroom walls in the 1980's.  I hadn't thought about it in years, and very well may have never thought of it again, if this Andy Friedman Shoebox Treasures card hadn't appeared on eBay.  When I saw it for the first time, the memory of that home drawn "poster" immediately came back to me.

I had no prior knowledge about this set, or Tim Wallach's inclusion in it.  When the first one of these popped up on eBay, I impulsively bought it (at an inexcusably high price, as I've gone from paying $6 to $1 for them).  I should have done a quick google search, as I sort of assumed it must be an insert, but instead I just said "take my money now." Turns out it's just a normal base card in a set.

The set is comprised of 100 cards, pulled from between 1952 and present, reimagined in water colors by an artist named Andy Friedman.  I am extremely pleased that Wallach was included in the checklist, and with the choice of card to recreate.  Andy Friedman clearly has good taste.

There also appears to be about 20-30 variations of this card of different individually numbered scarcity and sparkles.  I've added a few, but haven't looked into the exact number of variations that are out there.  Given the prices I've seen on some of them, I don't think tracking them all down will be a huge priority, unless something changes.  I did a search online and saw boxes of this product going for $80, with 7 cards per pack and only 4 packs for box.  I'm a stranger to "high end" releases, and I would call those prices high end.  

My understanding is that the collector's who like that kind of product also like lots of numbered variations, so it makes sense there would be a lot of variations.  Given how much I like the base card, there could be 200 variations and I wouldn't mind.  It's cards like this one that remind me why I collect in the first place and why I'm still collecting cards now, nearly 45 years after opening my first packs.

Number of this card in my collection: 6


Monday, October 27, 2025

Williamsburg, VA



This extremely eclectic mix of 12 Wallach cards was sent by David of Williamsburg, Virginia.  This is by my count (which is admittidly prone to be wrong) the 3rd year in a row David as sent me cards.  David runs the excellent CardBoredem blog, which you should click the link below (or this text here) to check out.  David sends out his cards in the very nice cardboard mailers pictured above with the bash brothers on them.  One of these years I'm going to get around to having something similar done for this blog, but until then I'll just continue to be impressed by his.

Included in this mix, were 4 nicely miscut 1982 Fleers.  I've said it a hundred times before and I'll say it again now, I love miscut cards.  That may sound insane to today's slabbers, but I think they're insane and have a lot of other less diplomatic ways to describe.

There was also an '83 O-Pee-Chee (one of my all-time favorites), an '88 Topps All-Star Tiffany (a design you'll be seeing a lot of here in the coming weeks), and the biggest surprise, a 2003 Donruss.  I first obtained a copy of this card in 2013.  tweleve years later my collection can now claim 3 copies of this card.  It was part of a Stadium Giveaway 59 card set in Montreal and there just don't seem to be many of them floating around.

Thanks for the cards David!

Updated Totals:






Monday, October 20, 2025

Tim Wallach Golf Tournament Vest




This item showed up on eBay a few weeks ago. I went ahead and placed a bid and ended up being the only bidder.  So now there is one more piece of clothing that I'll likely never wear in my house.  I don't mind, it's sort of cool, and I may pass it along to my father who golfs daily.

I had never heard of the "Tim Wallach Golf Tournament" affiliated with Cal St.-Fullerton, and the auction details weren't of much help either.  A google search though resulted in this article discussing the 2010 edition of the "annual event" (I'm not sure if it's still a thing).

Here's the description of the event from the article: 

Golfers looking for a tournament that offers a day of contest excitement and benefits a worthy cause can consider the May 17 Tim Wallach Golf Tournament and Auction sponsored by the Titan Athletics Club. The annual event is a fundraiser for the athletics program and student athletes.

I'm somewhat surprised I'd never seen one of these pop up on eBay before.  Then again, maybe this was the only year they gave away branded merch.  In any event, this one can be added to the archives.


Friday, October 17, 2025

Oceanside, NY

 

These 10 cards were sent by one of this blogs original contributors, Bo, of Oceanside, New York.  Bo has been sending me cards going all the way back to 2015.  Included in this batch was a 1983 O-Pee-Chee, a card that I don't see many of in the mail and is one of my favorite Wallach cards.

Thanks for the cards Bo!

Updated Totals:




Wednesday, October 15, 2025

St. Louis Park, MN


These 8 cards (and a Fleer Expos Sticker) were sent by Dan of Minnesota.  This is the third city in Minnesota Dan has sent cards from.  As fan of stamps (albeit, not a collector, I have enough problems, er, hobbies), I very much appreciate the stamps on this envelope.

Thanks for the cards Dan, and thanks for your patience in seeing them posted (Dan sent these back in July).

Updated Totals:

Friday, October 10, 2025

Chappell Hill, TX


I've been absent from posting all summer, and am trying to catch up on cards that have been sent.  Sean from Chappell Hill actually sent me cards twice.  Hopefully he hasn't been hitting refresh for three months wondering if they arrived.  Because they did, and here they are, belatedly.

As always, thanks for the cards!

Here are the updated totals:




Wednesday, October 1, 2025

Watertown, NY

These 27 cards were sent by the Nightowl.  A large portion of my mid-90's Wallach cards, as in, cards featuring Wallach as a Dodger, have been sent to me from Watertown.  Included in this bunch was an '82 Donruss, an Expos card, and rookie card at that.  Must have been sent to Greg's Upstate Dodger Depot by mistake.  There was also an LAPD DARE card.  These DARE subset cards are ones I've found it to be somewhat elusive over the years.

Thanks for the cards Greg!

Updated Totals:


Friday, May 16, 2025

Complete Color Run 2024 Topps Archives Fan Favorites


The above assortment represents the complete run of 2024 Topps Archives Wallach variations.  The complete "rainbow."  By my count, this is the fourth time Topps has produced a "rainbow" of variations for a Wallach card, and the first time I have completed the run.  Left to right these cards are numbered as follows: Base, Green #/99, Gold #/50, Blue #/25, Red #/25, Gold Superfractor #/1




As for it being the 4th time there has been a "color run" of Wallach cards produced by Topps, that number is up for debate, or at least, open to interpretation.  Here's a run down of what Topps has put out over the years.


2005 Topps Rookie Cup



Wallach was included in this set, and not just as an insert subset.  The base card was gray and then there were a variety of color combos, the ones I have in hand are shown here photographed together.  For my money, this is the run that most resembles a "rainbow" as they are numbered in the order of the color spectrum with only a "purple" (or violet) being absent.  It's also my favorite of the Wallach color runs. Left to right above, the base wasn't numbered with the colors have the following print runs: Red #/499, Orange #/399, Yellow #/299, Green #/199, Blue #/50

There were also a Silver (#/5) and a Gold (#/1) that I don't have, as well as printing plates.

Also included in the set as inserts was a "Rookie Reprint" run, that included a reprint of Wallach's '82 rookie, and variations of it in the form of a Topps Chrome reprint, a refractor reprint, and a "Rookie Relic."  I've managed to pick up at least one of each of those.

2017 Topps Archives



Wallach was previously included in the "Fan Favorites" subset of this product in 2017.  The variations I've added are shown above.  The white wasn't numbered, while the "Peach" was #/150, the Blue #/50, and Red #/25.

I'm missing the Gold #/1 and am not holding my breath at the prospect of ever landing one.

2019 Topps Archives



This product had a subset in tribute to the Montreal Expos that included Wallach.  All of the cards and variations were available as both autographs and unsigned, with the same colors in each and also being numbered the same.  It's the most difficult "color run" to see, as only the foil stamping changed colors on each variation.  I wouldn't argue too hard with anyone that says this isn't a "color run."  Even in hand it's very hard to see the different shades of some of the foil stamping.

Unsigned in Hand
Silver, Blue #/150, Green #/99, Red #/10

Unsigned Missing
Gold #/50, Black #/1

Signed in Hand
Silver, Green #/99, Gold #/50

Signed Missing Missing:
Red #/10, Black #/1


2004 Topps All-Time Fan Favorites


This isn't what I would call a color run, but as I was digging out the cards to photograph them, these were staring right at me, and I figured I may as well include them.  It's the first time I remember Topps did an on card Wallach auto or refractor.

Wednesday, April 30, 2025

Recent Online Purchases

I've been a little bit more active on eBay and Sportlots of late.  I'm sure this is due to the inclusion of Tim Wallach in the 2024 Topps Archives "Fan Favorite Autos" subset.  My desire to find each of the variants led me to checking ebay a lot more ofter, where I have a general "Tim Wallach" search saved and sorted by most recent.

The big find was a 1993 Memphis Chicks card for the extremely reasonable price of a dollar.  That card was one of my two "white whales" for decades.  I knew of its existence from around the time it was printed as a result of seeing a photo of it (mixed in with other cards from the set) in one of the old black and white, newsprint card magazines.  The memory as to which magazine has long since been lost to time.  The first one I ever found (back in 2013) was autographed, which was something of a disappointment, but I was still thrilled to finally own a copy, even with the sharpie blemish.  This is the 3rd copy I've added since, none of which are autographed.  It's still a lot of fun to find one of these in the wild.

O-Pee-Chee has long been a fascination of mine.  When I first started collecting cards, and Wallach cards, I knew about O-Pee-Chee and even had a small amount in my collection.  But I didn't end up owning a single Wallach O-Pee-Chee until years after Wallach had retired and the advent of eBay.  I still don't own very many, and when I saw a seller on Sportlots who had a good number of them, I took it upon myself to purchase them all.

There's a new documentary out about Dick Perez, who painted all the Donruss Diamond Kings cards.  I haven't watched it yet, but I'm not expecting him to explain why Tim Wallach was inexplicably passed over for his entire career, never appearing as a Diamond King, despite setting nearly every Montreal Franchise record from 1982-1992.  Wallach did however appear in the 1988 Leaf set as a "Canadian Great," which has long been a curiosity for me.  Did Perez opt for Wallach in '88 only to be overruled by Donruss?  Was it always the plan to use a different player for the Leaf set, and if so, which one got the "first choice?"  Maybe the documentary will address it, but I'd be shocked if it came up.  In any event, the O-Pee-Chee seller on Sportlots had a few of these available so of course I took them all.  

Below are the current numbers.

Updated Totals:



Monday, April 28, 2025

McKinney, Texas


These 85 cards were sent by Nick of McKinney, Texas.  A regular contributor, Nick has sent more cards to this effort than any other person in the history of the blog, and by a wide margin.  A few notable inclusions in this lot were 7 copies of the 1987 Indiana Blue Sox card and a 1993 O-Pee-Chee.  For literally decades I owned a single copy of the Indiana Blue Sox card, one I bought in a card shop as a kid.  It remained that way when I posted about the card for the first time back in 2012.  Then, out of nowhere, a reader sent me 325 copies of it in 2020.  I didn't see another one until these 7 arrived.  So while it's total number in my collection may seem to suggest it's not all that uncommon of card, those numbers are misleading.  The 1993 O-Pee-Chee is only my 10th copy of the card and first one I've added since 2020.

Thanks for the cards Nick!

Updated Totals:



Friday, April 25, 2025

Lutherville, Maryland



These 310 cards were generously sent by Bill of Lutherville, Maryland.  This is at least the third time Bill has sent cards going back to 2020, and this group will definitely move him up the ranks of the all-time total contributors to this blog.

The lot was heavy in 1993-95 Wallachs, a period that is actually somewhat under represented in my collection.  That's probably due mostly to the large number of different sets that were being produced during that period.  People weren't accumulating enormous amounts of cards from a single set, but rather a smaller number of cards from a larger number of options.  I also suspect it's due in part to a lack of sentimentalism for that period, so people are less inclined to sift through boxes of 1994 Studio and 1994 Triple Play looking for Wallachs.  I know when I am maxing out shipping categories on Sportlots, I tend to fill them out with 1980's Wallach cards rather than 1994 Donruss or 1995 Collector's Choice.

The three most interesting cards in this box were a 1990 Donruss Learning Series, 1990 Sportflics, and a 1994 LAPD DARE.  The '90 Learning series was the first one I've added since 2018 and only the second copy I've added since 2012.

Bill, thank you for the cards, I really appreciate them.

Updated Totals:


...and 2020 Topps Chad Wallach card.





Wednesday, April 16, 2025

2024 Topps Archives Fan Favorites Auto #95FF-TW Red #/10


Card Review: 8.9

It's very close, but I'm calling this "Red" variation my third favorite behind the white "base" (not sure it's fair to call it "base" as it is an insert and not part of the set) and "Blue" variations.  I will say that this red looks better in hand than it does in the scan.

With this "Red" variation, I am now in possession of at least one copy of each of the variations that are available.  I've heard it referred to as "completing the rainbow," but as the son of a public high school art teacher, I have far too much respect for the color spectrum to feel good about describing an assortment of white, green, two similar shades of gold, red and blue as a "rainbow."  That said, I'm definitely going to set aside my misgivings and call it a "rainbow" when I post about it on bluesky (and maybe here).

Number of this card in my collection: 1


Friday, April 11, 2025

2024 Topps Archives Fan Favorites Auto #95FF-TW Gold #/50


Card Review: 8.0

This "Gold" Archives Auto is numbered out of #/50 and is the fifth variation of this card that I've added.  All that remains is the "Red" version numbered out of #/10.  I rated this card the lowest of the five and that probably isn't entirely fair.  I think I'm just tired of them at this point.  Had this been the first one I picked up after the base card, it probably would have made a better first impression.  

I will add that I find it to be entirely too similar in color to the "1/1 Superfractor," from a distance you can't really tell them apart.  I would have preferred a brighter, less similar color, like a neon pink or orange, or a pastel purple or something.  A '91 Fleer yellow would be cool.  This gold is basically the "Superfractor" without the microchip texture all over it.

Something I do find to be a positive about these color variation autographed cards is the back.  The back has a very matte finish.  It's great, so great in fact, that it's frustrating.  To know that Topps has the ability to make "modern" baseball cards with raw matte backs, not exactly the same as, but certainly similar to the backs used for their first fifty years bugs me.  Why can't they do this as the standard back in the base set?  I would describe these backs as almost the same in feel as 1992 Topps, maybe a little better, but a little natural evolution in card stock quality is to be expected.  The only explanation I can come up with is a concern that the matte backs could "damage" the card surface of the the adjacent card in a pack?  Which, if is the case, just irritates me more.  Kids today need to get over their condition obsession.

In any event, I'm happy to add this, and at the risk of providing spoilers, barring a mistake by the post office a post about the "Red" variation should be appearing on this blog shortly.

Number of this card in my collection: 1






Wednesday, February 26, 2025

2024 Topps Archives Fan Favorites Auto #95FF-TW Superfractor #/1


Card Review: 8.7

This is it, the 2024 Topps Archives one of one "Superfractor."  And,...I guess it's okay.  I paid nearly three as as much as I ever had for a single Wallach card to own it (2005 Topps Rookie Cup Relic being the previous owner of that title) and I guess I'm okay with that?  When I saw this pop on eBay I immediately did a search to see what others were selling for.  The results weren't encouraging.  Guys I consider to be relatively anonymous players were coming in at around $400, which was a non-starter for me.  Regardless I went had and set a bid at $102 and walked away.  To my surprise, that was more than enough and the final auction price came in at just under $90.  Do I feel that's an insane price to pay for a baseball card printed in 2024, yes absolutely.  Had I known I was actually going to win the auction would I have bid that much?  Probably not.  My intention was to lose, post the pictures from the auction and blog about that.  But here I am, with my first "superfractor" in hand.

So what do I think?  I think it's okay.  The base card with the white border is still the best looking of these by a wide margin.  For purely display purposes, that's the one to go with.  I like this variation better than the green but not as much as the blue.  Though I don't have them in hand (and am not awaiting them in the mail either), I expect I'll like red better than than this and the gold looks about the same.  But I'll hold off to judge until, or if, I ever pick up the other two variations.  The ones currently for sale are asking nearly as much as I paid for this thing.

My primary complaint with this card is the sort of microchip pattern that the entire thing is covered in.  It's lame.  Worse yet, it's not limited to the border, it covers the enitire card.  To use the name of great new punk band out of the bay area, "Who Asked for This?" (check them on out spotify).

Number of this card in my collection: 1

OFFICIALLY HAVE THEM ALL.




Monday, February 24, 2025

Arlington, TN

These 19 cards were sent by Mark of Arlington, Tennessee.  This is at least the third time Mark has sent cards going back to 2020.  It was a nice assortment of Wallachs that included the not often seen 1995 Leaf Limited and 1991 Classic.   The 1991 Score Super Star is another Wallach that I don't see all that often but sort of flys under my radar.


Thanks for the cards Mark!

Updated Totals:



Tuesday, February 18, 2025

2024 Topps Archives Fan Favorites Auto #95FF-TW Green #/99

 
Card Review: 8.1

This is the "Green" variation of the 2024 Fan Favorites Archives.  These are numbered out of 99 copies.  It's now the third 2024 Archives I've added, along with the standard white border copy, and the blue "color match" variation numbered out of 25.  The green border just doesn't work well with the Expos baby blue uniforms.  Whenever I see these various border color variations, or pattern variations on Topps cards (typically in the base set every year, usually not ones that include Wallach) my first instinct is to imagine how they would look as a standard set design.  Sometimes I think they would work, more often, I don't.  That's not rooted in any hatred of brightly colored borders, I give them all a fair chance.  For instance, I love 1991 Fleer (yellow) and 1991 Donruss Series 2 (green).  I can't stand 1990 Donruss (red) or 1991 Donruss Series 1 (blue).  And sometimes I'm just sort of indifferent to them, like say 1986 Fleer (navy blue).  So I do feel my assesment is coming from a relatively unbiased place when I say this green just doesn't work for me, with this particular photo and likely wouldn't as a set either.  A final note, these borders have sort of a shiny, oil on water shimmer to them, as well as the top half of the card, that sort of fades to a more standard matte finish where the autograph is.  I actually kind of like it as a gimmick, but would find it offensive as an actual set.

In any event, there are three more of these variations out there, a gold (#/50), red (#/10), and single "superfractor" wonka ticket variation.  I know they're out there, but at the moment, the seller's on eBay want them more than I do.

Number of this card in my collection: 1


Thursday, February 13, 2025

Andover, MN


 These five cards were sent by "Crocodile Cards" of Andover, Minnesota.  This isn't the first time "Crocodile Cards" has sent cards, though he appears to have moved since last time.  Or maybe I just dropped the ball on adding it to my map of where cards have been sent from.  In either case, this city has been added.  (Check out his blog by clicking this link)

Thanks for the cards Croc!

Updated Totals:

Tuesday, February 11, 2025

Washington, D.C.

These six cards were sent by Colin from Washington D.C. (with an assist from his brother in Kansas City). You may notice that the envelope does not appear to be in mint condition.  That's not a result of over exuberance and excitement in opening it.  My parents have a new puppy, and during a recent visit, she got hold of some mail on my counter.  The cards escaped unharmed.  In fact, they're in as good of shape as any cards I've ever received.  Even the coloring on them is incredible.  On all of them, truly some sort of anomaly, or Colin and his brother ripped tons of wax as kids and only kept the best.  I don't know, but whatever the case, I'm happy to add them


Thanks for the cards Colin!


Wednesday, February 5, 2025

2024 Topps Archives Fan Favorites Auto #95FF-TW Blue #/25


Card Review: 9.0 
I've seen this card labeled as "color match" instead of "blue," in fact, that's how the listing on eBay I purchased it from titled it.  The baseball card database however is calling it "blue," and that makes more sense to me, so I'm calling it "blue" as well.  These blue variations are numbered out of 25, making it scarcer than the green (#/99) and gold (#/50), but more abundant that the red (#/10) and the 1 of 1 "superfractor."  

Currently I only have this and the basic one in hand, with a green on the way, but I've seen photos of all of them and the standard (regular?) version is the best looking by a wide margin.  Which, makes these a little unnecessary and redundant, doesn't it?  Then again, all of these are inserts and not part of the actual Archives checklist, so they're all sort of gimmick cards without a set to call home.  

In any event, personal distaste for inserts and on card autographs aside, it is more or less still a baseball card made by Topps that says "Tim Wallach" on both sides and has his picture on it, so I'll try to collect them all, though there is no universe where I actually pay any sort of premium to add the red or "superfractor" variations.


Number of this card in my collection: 1



Friday, January 31, 2025

2024 Topps Archives Fan Favorites Auto #95FF-TW


Card Review: 9.3 This is the first "new" Tim Wallach card Topps has put out since the 2019 Archives set, which included Wallach in the "Montreal Expos 50th" subset.  This card is done in the style of a 1995 Topps, and I'd call it a significant improvement over the original, which wasn't bad to begin with.  It's really a very nice looking card.  The vintage Expos baby blues work really well with this design (but they look so good they work well with just about any design).  By 1995 the Expos had stopped wearing these uniforms in favor of the bland grey script jerseys on the road, and Wallach was in his third year with the Dodgers regardless.  

The front photo of this card is as nice as any Topps ever put on a Wallach card.  While I can't prove it, I'll go ahead and say with an enormous degree of conifidence that this photo was taken during the same game, if not same at-bat, as the photo used on Wallach's 1990 Topps card (more photos below for comparison).  At some point I may get around to photo shopping this photo onto the 1990 card.  The primary back photo looks very familiar, but I couldn't place it to a card.  A quick google search shows it to be a Getty Image from 1988.

My nitpicks, to the extent that I have any, are two fold. The first is the autograph.  I know I'm fighting not just a losing battle, but a full on lost cause here, but I can't stand autographs on cards.  Ten year old kids getting a card autographed by a player at the ball park is great, I can name every player that ever signed for my brother and I as a kid.  But cards out of the pack shouldn't have sharpie or pen marks on them.  They're just a blemish, and the wrong kind of blemish (as in not a wax or gum stain, which of course are fine).  My second tiny complaint is with the tiny action photo on the back.  We've seen it before.  It's the photo used by Topps for Wallach's 2017 Archives card.  The guy played 13 seasons in Montreal, there's enough photographic evidence of it that Topps doesn't need to double up.

All in all, I am very pleased with the release of this card, and will make an effort to track down a sample of each of the two or three dozen variations that Topps probably made of it, so long as the prices aren't too insane.  So far I've seen four different colored and numbered variations, but I suspect there are more.  I'll update when I learn something definitive.


Number of this card in my collection: 2


Photo Comparisons

   
Original 1995 Topps vs. 2024 Topps Archives

 
Original 1995 Topps back vs. 2024 Topps Archives back


1990 Topps, photo taken at Shea Stadium, likely from same game.  Notice the batting gloves.

 
Getty Image from 1988 used for card back.  Small action photo on 2017 Archives below.

History of Topps Archives Fan Favorites Tim Wallach Autos:

   
2003 Topps Archives (left), 2017 Topps Archives (right)

2019 Topps Archives (left), 2024 Topps Archives (right)